By Ruth Brown, Idaho Reports 

Stories of a failing foster care system prompted both tears and visible anger among the committee members at Thursday’s Child Protection Oversight Committee meeting. 

The committee heard from current and former foster parents who brought complaints against the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare’s foster care system, including concerns about the agency’s grievance process and visits to biological families. One testifier shared their concern over sending a child in their care to visit their biological family when the foster parent had reason to believe the child had been sexually abused.  

Brian McCauley, the Region 3 chair for a citizen’s review panel, expressed open frustration with the foster system to the committee. He and his wife are former foster parents, but said they terminated their license after negative experiences with the system and a traumatic case. He argued there had been no meaningful change in the system over the last decade. 

McCauley said multiple foster parents have reached out to him over the last 10 years to talk about their issues with the system.  

“How is it that people from across Idaho reach out to me with these terrible stories begging for help?” McCauley said. “This objectively demonstrates our system is broken. Why would they reach out to me if there is a great system in place that was hearing their concerns?” 

He pointed to the number of foster children being housed in short-term rentals, such as AirBnBs, rather than foster homes. He added that after 10 years of increased funding, and studies from the Office of Performance Evaluations, he feels the state had made no progress. 

“I am frustrated beyond words when someone has the authority to change something, and either can’t or won’t,” McCauley said as his voice cracked. “At some point, those who have built the system need to accept accountability for where it’s at.” 

McCauley said he had no confidence in who is running the foster care system and urged legislators to use their influence to create change.  

“I am not willing to admit that it can’t be changed,” McCauley said. “I am not willing to accept that this is the best we can hope for or accept that this is the best provide for the most vulnerable in our state. And frankly, I am not willing to stay quiet anymore.” 

About 3,000 Idaho children are put in out-of-home placements each year, according to IDHW.  

Senate Majority Leader Kelly Anthon, R-Burley, expressed serious concern about an ongoing problem.  

“It shouldn’t take 10 seconds, much less 10 years,” Anthon told the committee. “I have a high level of confidence in Director (Dean) Cameron. I have a high level of confidence in a lot of people at the Department of Health and Welfare. But those who are failing need to go, and they need to go post haste,”  

“If 1% of it is true, there should be hell to pay,” Anthon said about the stories McCauley shared. 

Anthon acknowledged that every system and every department has failures. 

“But when I see a pattern over 10 years, I’m telling you right now, everybody who’s involved in that you better watch out, because I’m going to go on a warpath,” he said. 

Senate Assistant Majority Leader Abby Lee, R-Fruitland, said she speaks to foster families regularly who were concerned about retaliation if they testified publicly about the issues. 

IDHW’s Andi Blackwood said the department hopes to improve the grievance process and receive feedback from the foster parents, setting up a group of foster parents for recommendations.  

“What has been holding the department back?” asked Senate Minority Leader Melissa Wintrow, D-Boise. “I’m struggling right now.” 

Cameron Gilliand, Administrator for the Division of Family and Community Services in IDHW addressed some of the committee’s concerns. As he approached the podium, he acknowledged he is the person responsible for the overall system, something multiple committee members had asked. 

Gilliand said as of Thursday, DHW had 22 foster children currently in short-term rentals. Over the course of 2023, 175 children stayed at short-term rentals, rather than being placed with foster families.  

“As Director Cameron has become the interim director (of IDHW) he has told us we need to shut them down, and that is what we’re going to do,” Gilliand said. “…Part of problem in doing this is we have to close the front door. How do we keep kids from needing the short-term rental? How do find placements for them?”  

Gilliand said it is a process that takes time, and it requires keeping children safe. DHW must either find a foster family to take care of the child or a residential facility, if it’s appropriate, that will take care of the child.  

DHW has increased payment to $150 a day for foster parents who agreed to take an additional child.  

“We have made mistakes. I chase them daily. I talk to foster parents daily,” Gilliand said. “…It’s very important to me personally that we watch over these kids and that the system works. We have problems. We have issues. We need to address them, and I will spend whatever time is needed to address them.” 

PLANNED CHANGE 

Lawmakers discussed two draft bills in the committee, but both will need to go through the legislative committee process.  

The first bill, proposed by Lee, would create a new section of law that states if DHW places a child in a short-term rental, temporary shelter, or congregate care setting, the department must notify the court within seven days of the placement. Additionally, DHW cannot place children under the age of 12 in rentals unless DHW’s director gives written approval to put a foster child if the child is age 3 or older, the child is part of a sibling group, and at least one of the siblings is 13 or older. Another exemption is if the child is age 6 or older and has been taken into shelter care through the emergency removal process. Teenage mothers who are in the foster care system would also be allowed to bring their child. 

A second piece of legislation, sponsored by Rep. Britt Raybould, R-Rexburg, would create an ombudsman office to monitor health and social services for vulnerable adults and children in state custody. The office of the ombudsman would operate independently of the courts and of the Department of Health and Welfare and would establish a procedure for receiving, examining and resolving complaints. The ombudsman would also be charged with gathering and analyzing data to discern patterns and problems in health and social services.  

Raybould said the intent was not to point a finger at any one individual. 

“We have a duty, and right now we are failing,” Raybould said. “We need to do better.” 


Ruth Brown | Producer

Ruth Brown grew up in South Dakota and her first job out of college was covering the South Dakota Legislature. She’s since moved on to Idaho lawmakers. Brown spent 10 years working in print journalism, including newspapers such as the Idaho Statesman and Idaho Press, where she’s covered everything from the correctional system to health care issues. She joined Idaho Reports in 2021 and looks forward to telling stories about how state policy can impact the lives of regular Idahoans.